by
Shobha Aggarwal
The law of contempt in India generally
dissuades people from articulating fair criticism of the judiciary. As Lord
Denning said, judges do not need contempt jurisdiction to uphold their dignity.
In that spirit, I venture to write about what I experienced at the Delhi High
Court on 30 October 2026. The inconvenience caused to lawyers and litigants by
the suspension of judicial work for the Court’s 60th anniversary celebrations has,
to my knowledge, so far escaped public comment.
I have been a member of the Bar
since 1989. On 30 October 2026, I reached the Delhi High Court at about 9.30
a.m., my usual time so that I could
find a convenient parking space inside the court premises. The previous day had been spent preparing final
arguments in two connected appeals, one of which has been pending since 2017.
The matters had been listed repeatedly for final hearing over the past two years,
and I was hopeful that the final hearing would at last proceed. I carried with
me a heavy bag full of judgments and other material required for the hearing.
I was sitting in the Ladies Bar
Room when at 9.37 a.m. I received a circular forwarded by my co-counsel. He apparently
forwarded it to me immediately upon receiving it. Until then, I had not the
slightest inkling that a grand function was being organised to commemorate
sixty years of the Delhi High Court. See circular.
After reading the circular I asked
around. A few lawyers had heard that a function was to take place, but nobody
knew whether courts would continue functioning after 12.30 p.m. The circular
itself was of little help. It dealt mainly with parking arrangements and was
silent on whether regular judicial work would continue for the rest of the day.
The circular does request the President/Hony. Secretary to bring it to the
knowledge of members of the Bar. But I did not receive any notification
regarding the function.
I searched the Delhi High Court
website to ascertain whether any announcement had been made regarding the
function. There was none. The cause list contained no information. There was
nothing to indicate that judicial work would effectively come to an end at
12.30 p.m. In short, there was no information on the Delhi High Court website
regarding the “grand function” organised to commemorate its sixtieth
anniversary. Several judges of the Supreme Court also attended the event.
Whether lawyers and litigants appearing before the Supreme Court had any
advance information about it, I do not know.
In the High Court lobby, I
spoke to a few lawyers. They were equally confused and had no idea whether the
courts would function after 12.30 p.m. One of them read the circular on my
phone and, applying his legal skills to its interpretation, remarked that since
it referred to arrangements "from 12.30 p.m. onwards", it meant that
the courts themselves would not function after 12.30 p.m. As it turned out, his
interpretation was correct.
I finally approached the Court
Master, who confirmed that all courts would rise at 12.30 p.m. When my matter
was taken up, it was adjourned. The order did not record that the adjournment
was occasioned by the anniversary celebrations. I do not know whether other
courts recorded in their orders that matters were being adjourned on account of
the anniversary celebrations. The obvious question is this: why were lawyers
and litigants left to discover such an important fact through word of mouth on
the very morning of the event?
Every adjournment has a human
cost. Litigants travel long distances. Many take leave from work and incur
considerable expense. Some have been waiting for years for their matters to be
heard. Lawyers spend days preparing for hearings. None of this appears in
statistics on pendency, but it forms the lived reality of the justice system.
Several questions arise:
· Why was there no public announcement well in
advance that court work would be curtailed?
· Why was a function of this nature organised
during court hours?
· Why could it not have been held on a Saturday or
after court hours?
· Why were lawyers and litigants expected to bear
the consequences of a decision in which they had no voice?
These questions are not
confined to one anniversary function. They go to a larger issue concerning the
culture of our courts.
Whenever valuable court time is
lost to ceremonial functions, swearing-in ceremonies, farewell references,
condolence references or similar events, the burden falls not on the
institution but on litigants. The inconvenience is borne by those who can least
afford it. The occasion of the Delhi High Court’s sixtieth anniversary should
have been used to reaffirm a simple principle: that litigants and lawyers
deserve transparency, consideration and respect; that judicial time is a public
resource held in trust for the people; and that court work should not lightly
give way to ceremonial functions.
In the interest of justice, I
submit that all ceremonial functions, including but not limited to swearing-in
ceremonies, farewell references, condolence references and other similar
events, should be held before or after court hours so that regular judicial
work is not disrupted and inconvenience to litigants and lawyers is avoided.
Such functions should not be organised without transparency or adequate prior
notice to all those affected by such a decision.
One hopes that such incidents will not recur
and that litigants and members of the Bar will be accorded the dignity and
respect they deserve.
Author is an advocate
practicing at Delhi High Court. Views are personal.

No comments:
Post a Comment